What to Consider When Outsourcing A Survey Project
Outsourcing is a valuable resource in many industries for successfully
delivering on short-term, specialized projects—without stretching
your staff to the breaking point. Survey projects are certainly no exception.
Selecting the right survey vendor is probably the single most important
step in a successful outsourcing engagement. Consider the following:
1. Why Do You Want To Outsource The Survey?
Even companies with internal
survey staff frequently need to use outside experts to get answers.
The reason to use an external vendor varies but we find they generally revolve
around:
Assessing the scope of the project (large sample or multi-region) – You
may have the internal resources for a small survey project but need to bring
in an outside vendor for a large, complex project.
Avoiding bias – Selecting an outside firm helps you assure that the
data is not skewed by internal bias. Internal resources may be predisposed,
inadvertently or not, in seeing a particular result. Using an outside firm
helps avoid biased results.
Requiring expertise beyond what you or your staff can do internally. For
example, extensive modeling or specialized methodologies.
Controlling capital expenditure. Saving money may not be the only reason
to outsource, but it's certainly a major factor. Outsourcing converts fixed
costs into variable costs, releases capital for investment elsewhere in
your business, and allows you to avoid large expenditures in the early stages
of your business. And outsourcing may enable you to direct more of your
capital into revenue-generating activities.
Increasing efficiency. Companies that try to do everything themselves often
have much higher expenses, slower response times, and can find themselves
spending too much energy and mind share on peripheral tasks. An outside
provider's existing infrastructure and economies of scale can give your
organization an important competitive advantage.
Reducing labor costs. Hiring and training staff for short-term or one-time
projects can be very expensive; and temporary employees don't always measure
up to needs and expectations. Outsourcing lets you focus your human resources
and talent where you need them most.
Starting new projects quickly. A good outsourcing firm has the resources
to start a project right away. Handling the same project in-house might
take weeks or months to research and evaluate options, purchase and install
equipment and technology, hire the right people, train them, and provide
support to everyone involved. And if a project requires major capital investments
(such as purchasing and installing computer hardware and software, or developing
software systems internally), then the startup process can be even more
difficult.
Focusing on your core business. Every business has limited resources, and
every manager has limited time and attention. Outsourcing can help your
business avoid shifting its focus to peripheral, non-core activities, and
instead maintain focus on core competencies, your areas of expertise and
specialty, and the work that serves your customers most.
Leveling the playing field. Most small businesses and individuals can't
afford to match the in-house support services and infrastructure that larger
companies–or companies dedicated to providing a specific service–maintain.
Outsourcing can help small businesses act 'big' by giving them access to
similar economies of scale, efficiency and expertise that large companies
enjoy.
Reducing risk. Every business investment carries a certain amount of risk.
Markets, competition, government regulations, financial conditions and technologies
all change very quickly. Outsourcing providers assume and manage much of
this risk for you, and they generally are much better at deciding how to
avoid risk in their areas of expertise.
2. What Is Their Commitment To Quality?
This may sound obvious, but you will want to see tangible ways that the
vendor is committed to quality. An investment in quality products and services
shows a commitment to the customer. You do not want to make an investment
with a company that does not stand behind and take pride in their products.
Anything less than total commitment, is a red flag for your project.
Questions to Ask:
- Do they hire experienced staff?
- What kind of ongoing training to they do?
- How much do they invest in technology?
- Do they survey their existing clients?
- Do they certify their staff or processes?
- Do they follow a formal quality program?
3. What Is Their Primary Expertise And Level Of Experience?
Your survey is important and you want an experienced vendor. Proven experience
can provide you a level of security in choosing your vendor, but the expertise
they can bring to the table can be immeasurable. Since you are considering
outsourcing the project, it's possible you don’t have the extensive
knowledge about survey design and implementation that a seasoned vendor
brings to the table. They may have an idea or solution you never thought
of and may find valuable. It may, in fact, be the main success factor for
your project.
Experience
- Project Team - Have they been with this company long? Are they familiar
with your industry and/or have they worked on similar projects? What
type of formal research training do they have?
- Project History - Has this company worked on this type of project before?
A field service firm may have enough interviewers for a project,
but may not be experienced in more advanced methodologies.
- Industry Experience - Does this vendor work with other companies in
your industry? You may or may not need this industry experience, depending
on your internal resources, but if you do it should be identified
in the selection process.
The point in hiring an outside vendor for a survey project is to tap into
the vendor's expertise. Therefore, it makes little sense to demand that
potential vendors conduct a study the same way you would if it were an
internal project.
4. What Are Your Budget Requirements?
Most vendors, once you have viewed their recommendations, will be willing
to discuss budget issues if you feel their bids are out of your range. Likewise,
you should be willing to tailor your questions, sample sizes, and topics
according to your available budget.
For example, a tight budget probably won’t work with an 8-page mail survey.
You want your survey to be a success so be realistic in your expectations.
Work with your vendor to reduce the size and complexity of your survey, without
compromising the results you need.
5. What Are Your Survey Specifications?
Prior to selecting a vendor, you should have an idea of your survey specifications.
A good way to start identifying what you want to survey is to work backwards.
Define what results would give you the best information and tailor your
specifications around those results.
Questions to ask:
- Who is the target audience (gender, age, job title/responsibility, product
usage, etc.)?
- Where do you want the study conducted (local, regional, national, global,
etc.)?
- What would you like to ask them (sample questions)?
6. What Is Your Timing For The Survey?
Consider the following:
- When do you expect to start the study?
- Have you established all timelines and milestones?
- Is the vendor able to accommodate your timing needs?
- Do any constraints exist that require specific timing (i.e. around advertising
campaigns, staff not being available, etc.)?
- When will the results be required and in what format (i.e. top-line,
draft, formal report or presentation)?
- Do you have long-term requirements? If so, is the vendor established
and reliable?
7. Does The Vendor Assign A Project Manager Or One Point Of Contact?
It can be difficult as well as detrimental to the project if you are
passed to three different people every time you call. To avoid this
it is important to have one point of contact, preferably a project
manager dedicated to your survey. Try to avoid the sales representative
being your sole contact. Project managers have more hands-on experience
and can pinpoint problem areas due to their experience.
Look for project managers that:
- Are responsible for the definition and implementation of the project.
- Will be the central contact for the client.
- Communicate and respond proactively to resolve any issues and initiates
the involvement of any additional resources.
- Lead the internal project team, which includes a representative from
each functional area. The team should work together to deliver the
project specifications.
- Supervise forms and materials printing, distribution, receiving, scanning,
and reporting, and provides the data to the client in a timely manner.
- Identify when service requirements change, documenting changes and
corresponding fee adjustments in a written change of scope.
8. What Is Their Reputation and Can You Call References?
References are a good way to evaluate a firm, but keep in mind that most
vendors will give you names of firms that will say mostly positive things.
It is always a good practice to ask specifically for references of firms
similar to your own.
Knowing that references will most likely give positive responses, it is
also effective to question your potential vendor about their reputation.
You can learn a lot and find the information valuable. Years of experience
and long-term customers are always a good sign.
Questions to ask the vendor include:
- How long have they been in business?
- How are their financials?
- How many current customers do they have?
- How many surveys do they process annually?
- What is the average size of their survey projects? What is the size
range that they typically work within? Do they have any large-scale survey
experience?
- What is their longest customer relationship?
- Have they done prior work for your company?
- Do they have similar project in similar industries?
- What is their quality process?
9. Scope of Resources
When choosing a survey vendor, you are trusting that they will be able
to deliver on your project. You need to make sure they can meet your needs
for the foreseeable future and that you are selecting a vendor that will
back up what they promise.
If your prospective vendor can not answer the following questions with
ease, you should question their reliability.
- Do they have adequate staff for this project? Can they ramp up their
staff quickly, if needed?
- What is their disaster recovery plan?
- What technology are they using?
- Can they handle the volume or complexity of your project? Do they have
experience with large-scale projects? Can they give an example of
a complex survey that they have implemented?
- What is their backup plan for data? What is their backup plan for equipment
failures?
- What level of security do they offer for the facility and the data?
Find out from Procesing Services what their current secutiyu status is.
10. Data Analysis and Reporting
In the end, the reason you conducted the survey is for the response data.
It is the time when you get the information you were seeking and make decisions.
You should decide what services you are looking for from your vendor regarding
analysis and reporting. You may want to do the analysis yourself or have
the vendor offer some analysis and recommendations. At the very least we
find that all of our customers want to be able to filter the data and display
results in a variety of formats to maximize your findings.
Most survey services offer basic data reporting. This gives you a look
at the data but does not allow for further analysis. We find that simple
reporting of data is not enough. Organizations want to take different looks
at their data to answer questions that arise during analysis. You want to
ask your vendor what reporting and analysis options are available for your
project. If they only offer stagnant reports without the ability to request
ad hoc or further analysis, you should move on.
At the minimum you should see a variety of analysis choices and the further
option of a stronger analytics package, if needed. At Pearson NCS, we find
that our OLAP tool, Consilio, meets most statistical needs, but we also
offer the following analytic methods:
- Frequency
- Variance
- Minimum
- Sum
- Maximum
- Skewness
|
- Range
- Kurtosis
- Mean
- Confidence
- Median
- Correlation
|
- Mode
- Chi-Square
- Standard Deviation
- Confidence
- Significance
|
Copyright © 1995-2007, Pearson
Education, Inc. or its affiliates. All rights reserved.
This document may not be photocopied, reproduced, translated,
or converted to any electronic or machine readable form in whole or in
part without prior written approval. If portions of this document are
quoted in scholarly research, credit must be attributed to Pearson Education,
Inc.